Review: YOUR HOST Features a Fantastic Jackie Earle Haley Role in a Disappointing SAW Rerun

A Saw knockoff starring Jackie Earle Haley as a murderous Chuck Woolery type? An intriguing selling point, but frustrating in practice. Your Host tries to wrestle with cancel culture in the entertainment business while also slathering audiences in gore, which never gels together. Director DW Medoff has a secret weapon in Haley, who does his best to lead Your Host as an enigmatic John Kramer-y emcee, but Joey Miller’s screenplay isn’t properly calibrated. All the “killer gameshow host” bits are aces, and yet the story stumbles through its conflicts, rendering Haley’s showtime dramatics as afterthoughts.

Your Host is a single-location thriller in terms of gameplay, as four friends find themselves victims of Haley’s psychotic gameshow host, Barry Miller. His contestants are young friends who find themselves in an abandoned warehouse, chained à la Jigsaw to a wall. The audience is mannequins, the competitions all have violent consequences, and the jackpot is survival. Only one player can win: the birthday girl Anita (Ella-Rae Smith), the trust-fund douchebro James (Jamie Flatters), the unassuming Matthew (David Angland), or the feisty Melissa (Joelle Rae).

There is, as alluded to, more to Your Host than just Barry Miller’s bloodthirsty games like the “Wheel of Pain” (no fortune), or a brutal take on “Rock, Paper, Scissors.” The reason why Anita and her companions find themselves as variety show prisoners is not by chance. Barry’s motivations are vengeful, but Miller’s screenplay doesn’t quite understand how to land its messages. The messy web of false accusations, sexual misconduct, and studio hush money leaves thematic explorations in a tangle, which stings worse given the severity of topics covered. Once Your Host becomes more than just a nightmare spin on the Game Show Network, the concept deflates.

It’s a shame, because Haley is doing tremendous work as this high-energy deviant who takes pleasure in torturing his contestants. There’s a Joker-esque quality about Haley’s performance, drawing from Joaquin Phoenix’s Arthur Fleck, but also a wholesome primetime television cheese about his presentation. Barry’s rainbow suspenders and bowtie juxtapose his cracked-in-half, almost Ronald Reagan-like mask. Haley bounces about with uncontrollable glee while committing heinous acts of harm that include acids, power tools, and hydraulic presses, reminiscent of a 1990s Jim Carrey except more devilish and maniacal. He understands how to accentuate pitch-black humor in the face of pure evil, stealing every scene.

Disappointingly, Your Host doesn’t know how to support its shining star. Anita’s crew is unlikeable from the start, intentionally so, but in a way that doesn’t help us care for their future survival. Kill sequences pick up the slack, especially an outstandingly repulsive first kill that sets a jaw-dropping tone, but it’s just visual stimulation. The narrative’s choppy reveals of ultimate truths take away from the otherwise zany chaos of Barry’s flashy theatrics, making us wish the story kept things much simpler. On Barry’s “stage,” where lights flash and cameras record the festivities for his own collection, Medoff is firing on all cylinders. The rest, in its current state, doesn’t have the wherewithal to punch its messages home.

In choice doses, Your Host is a showcase for Jackie Earle Haley—perhaps redemption for A Nightmare on Elm Street. But, when addressed as a total package, Your Host bumbles through its cutthroat commentaries on #MeToo’s cultural impact. Medoff’s carnage is noteworthy, and his management of Haley is immaculate, yet there’s a sour taste left by the rest of what’s involved. Barry Miller is a genre star who deserves the attention, albeit just in a better, more fleshed-out movie.

Movie Score: 2.5/5