In The Saviors, there aren't mixed messages—but its approach isn't always crystal clear. As satire, there's a biting take on how to save a marriage through suburban xenophobia, which raises frightening questions and sneaks in wince-about-it laughs. Directed by Kevin Hamedani and co-written by Travis Betz, this indie mystery about terrorist conspiracies and post-apocalyptic premonitions takes aim at "the outsider" with caustic bigotry that works, though maybe not as well as the production believes. Communication is key, whether in struggling marriages or across cultural boundaries, but it's also key to conveying tonal expectations to the audience, which The Saviors does not do fluently.

Adam Scott and Danielle Deadwyler star as Sean and Kim Harrison, dead-end partners on the verge of divorce. Sean sleeps on the couch, or in his grungy "boy cave," while Kim fantasizes about their more adventurous, passionate selves. As an added complication, Sean and Kim are forced to rent out their guest house to pay their mortgage. Enter Amir (Theo Rossi) and Jahan Razi (Nazanin Boniadi), their newest tenants. They're polite, soft-spoken, but Sean begins to suspect they're making a bomb from scratch, painting them as Muslim extremists who want to kill the President of the United States. Maybe he's right, or maybe he's racist … the American way.

The duo of Scott and Deadwyler is, as written, deep in the depression of a love-fading romance and damn good in the scenario. Scott falls into the red-pill trap that trickles down from older generations who subscribe their children to Neo-Nazi propaganda mailing lists, finding a distraction in his blunt-and-judgmental conspiracy brain. Deadwyler plays a stronger-willed, more accepting partner, leaning into her ability to paint Sean a jobless, lackadaisical fool. But as occurrences grow weirder, with thundering bangs and green lights cutting through the midnight silence, their shared paranoia is convincingly conveyed. You're supposed to feel sketchy, as the curious couple tries to fill in the blanks on their own. Scott and Deadwyler dive headfirst into the comedic discomfort, material that elevates in their hands.

Of course, The Saviors doesn't work without Rossi and Boniadi. As Amir and Jahan, they ensure that, at every turn, we know something is fishy—but it can't be the obvious answer. All the subjective gazes of neighborhood watch anxieties are thrust upon Amir and Jahan, who confess the plight of refugees. Boniadi has less to do, since Jahan is mute, but Rossi has this suspicious air about him at all times, the way his darting, pleading eyes contradict the words that escape his mouth. They play the "stranger" or "invader" well, depending on the perspective Hamedani chooses. It's like The 'Burbs or Summer of 84, except way more poignantly relatable. Humor and horror stem from the same sense of radicalized disturbia; this unrest that exists because average civilians are so susceptible to fearmongering from MAGA-esque leadership.

Despite the The Savior's bastardization of patriotism, it is frequently humorous. It's the little things, like Sean's incel-adjacent spirals about sleeper cells, or Kim's manipulation of Daveed Diggs (playing a flirty bar patron) to go on a mini recon mission. There's also Greg Kinnear as Jim Clemente, this grungy, aging private eye who exists as this enigma of both stupidity and results. It makes perfect sense that Sean's MAGA-verse sister, Cleo (Kate Berlant), is having a behind-closed-doors fling with Jim—just one more poor decision in a string of missteps. Or, like most characters, a poor decision hidden from sight to avoid ridicule. Because that's what The Saviors says the most about: communication. Everyone's got their secrets, but they're predicated on unfair assumptions about others that could be cleared up with a simple conversation.

These themes, the rift that exists in our country between what our government says about citizens versus immigrants, drum up feelings of discomfort that should sting. Hamedani's able to alleviate some of that awfulness with pointed humor, skewering the ridiculous lengths we'll go to validate our own narratives. But there's something about the film's structure, especially as heavier genre elements veer the story into more fantastical realms (or at least another red herring of a possibility). As is, with such a focus on Scott and Deadwyler's characters, the humor of gross biases rekindling a romance sometimes feels like a strange formula, despite its scathing satire. It's an ambitious film with splendid ideas and plenty of value, yet could use a conceptual recalibration.

It's that out-of-whackness that leaves me stuck on The Saviors. I like it! And yet, there's a funk I can't shake about its current configuration. I wanted to be fully swept up in the romantic suspense of stakeout will-they-won't-they banter, along with the tension of fearing what could be hidden behind thin, Amazon Prime'd curtains in Sean and Kim's on-site rental. As is, it's a quirky, comical, and cautionary tale about the broken American mindset that nails its peeping-tom thrills, but isn't as airtight as it thinks in execution.

Movie Score: 3/5

  • Matt Donato
    About the Author - Matt Donato

    Matt Donato is a Los Angeles-based film critic currently published on SlashFilm, Fangoria, Bloody Disgusting, and anywhere else he’s allowed to spread the gospel of Demon Wind. He is also a member of the Critics Choice Association. Definitely don’t feed him after midnight.

  • Matt Donato
    About the Author : Matt Donato

    Matt Donato is a Los Angeles-based film critic currently published on SlashFilm, Fangoria, Bloody Disgusting, and anywhere else he’s allowed to spread the gospel of Demon Wind. He is also a member of the Critics Choice Association. Definitely don’t feed him after midnight.