There's something snug and quaint about the J-Horror stylings of Never After Dark. Writer and director Dave Boyle explores an affable take on the afterlife that becomes a terrifying assessment of the living. It's a movie with robust spirituality and centered composure, as an upside-down story leaks insidious traits. Boyle hits on the welcoming notes of ghostly guests, think The Frighteners adjacent, while still honoring the horrific traditions of skin-crawling Japanese genre classics. It's warmhearted, obscure, and thoroughly creepy all at once, which makes for a rivetingly free-flowing watch.

Moeka Hoshi stars as Airi, a vagabond medium aided by the spirit of her deceased older sister, Miku (Kurumi Inagaki). Airi's latest assignment brings her to a woodland hotel, hired by the new owner and excitable supernatural believer, Teiko (Tae Kimura), and—with less enthusiasm—Teiko's son, Gunji (producer Kento Kaku). The request is simple: cleanse the country hideaway of a suspected apparition. So, Airi and Miku get to work, tag-teaming another paranormal investigation from multiple planes of existence—except, this is far from just another routine gig.

Enter Mutsuo Yoshioka as "The Gaping-Mouth Man," the hotel's disturbing squatter. As Airi conducts her inspection of the property, she encounters Yoshioka's shambling ghoul, with its torn-open mouth, almost like a Yautja's mug. He's gross and decayed, scratching at a cabinet door while his nails split; a gruesome sight that takes us back to the haunted awfulness of J-Horror nightmares. It sends a proper chill down our spine, but the once-alive man is only one piece to a puzzle that's far more complicated than a solitary entity causing evil. 

It's a pleasure to watch Airi work, bantering with big sister Miku in reflective surfaces. She follows strict rules that will no doubt lead to trouble later, like not working at night, when the veil between the living and the dead is thinnest. Boyle respects the tropes of mediums, including a ceremonial candle that acts as Airi's signature artifact, granting her access to the spirit world. But he's also playful about Airi's personality, and how she's nonchalantly too cool about her duties, even taking a day off to sip beers and dance about the hotel despite the Gaping-Mouth Man's appearance. It's a jovial flavor of confidence that's endlessly entertaining as she twirls and flails around the undead figure, set against clipping. collaborator and composer Jonathan Snipes' swinging original bop, "Silhouette."

However, Never After Dark isn't all goofs and good-natured Ghostbusters jokes. There's a seedy, sickening undertone that spreads like a virus as Miku warns Airi that something far more sinister is afoot. Boyle bends expectations into a new shape worth fearing by keeping an air of suspense about living threats versus wayward souls. Gunji's disbelief and treatment of Airi paint him in a suspicious light, while the more we learn about Mr. Gaping Mouth, the worse Boyle's examinations of humanity become. There's a malevolence that's always there, yet the film's bread and butter hides in how the story's bleakness evolves.

What's special about Never After Dark is how it stews in convention until flipping the script, but it's hardly cheap deception. Boyle skillfully manipulates the stakes of his film by confirming that there is, indeed, an afterlife, while lulling us into a sense of safety through Airi's fearless behavior. Then, once we're all cozy, he turns the page on evils that are hiding in plain sight. It's almost like a game, the way Boyle's script toys with Airi, and it's impressive to see Hoshi own such a dynamic role. The balance between light and dark, yin and yang, is so fragile; Hoshi's seer tests the limitations of what she can help from both sides. There's plenty for the actress to wrestle with in a conflicted character at odds with her faith, her family, and herself, and it all comes together in this delicately despicable package.

Never After Dark is one of those full-meal horror experiences that checks box after box. Boyle's bewitching J-Horror examination of mortality and monsters flickers with this addictive liveliness despite its deceased characters. It's this grim tale that's somehow glowing; an intelligently plotted and viciously enacted haunting that weaponizes familiarity. A delicious genre treat so artfully shot that'll have you both smiling and hiding within minutes of each reaction, assembled by a filmmaker with keen vision, and more importantly, confidence in not only the material, but the genre at large.

Movie Score: 4/5

  • Matt Donato
    About the Author - Matt Donato

    Matt Donato is a Los Angeles-based film critic currently published on SlashFilm, Fangoria, Bloody Disgusting, and anywhere else he’s allowed to spread the gospel of Demon Wind. He is also a member of the Critics Choice Association. Definitely don’t feed him after midnight.

  • Matt Donato
    About the Author : Matt Donato

    Matt Donato is a Los Angeles-based film critic currently published on SlashFilm, Fangoria, Bloody Disgusting, and anywhere else he’s allowed to spread the gospel of Demon Wind. He is also a member of the Critics Choice Association. Definitely don’t feed him after midnight.